CostLens
Home › Compare

Staten Island vs New York

United States vs United States · 23 km apart

Staten Island

United States

$1,328

single / month

Cheaper overall
VS

New York

United States

$1,664

single / month

Category Breakdown (USD)

ExpenseStaten IslandNew YorkCheaper
Meal at an inexpensive restaurant$11.93$14.63Staten Island
Three-course meal for two, mid-range$47.70$58.50Staten Island
Cappuccino$3.58$4.39Staten Island
Monthly groceries (single person)$270$332Staten Island
Monthly public transport pass$43.73$53.63Staten Island
Basic utilities for an 85m² apartment$115$141Staten Island
Internet (60 Mbps, unlimited)$33.39$40.95Staten Island
Fitness club membership$33.39$40.95Staten Island
Cinema ticket$8.75$10.73Staten Island
One-bedroom apartment in city centre$767$990Staten Island
One-bedroom apartment outside centre$533$689Staten Island
Three-bedroom apartment in city centre$1,600$2,066Staten Island
Total single-person budget$1,328$1,664Staten Island
Average net salary$4,134$5,070

Verdict

Staten Island is cheaper overall. A single-person monthly budget in Staten Island runs about $1,328 versus $1,664 in New York — a difference of roughly 25%.

Salary-adjusted, New York leaves more disposable income after basic expenses. Both figures are model estimates — see each city page for local-currency detail.

Full cost of living in Staten Island  ·  Full cost of living in New York

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Staten Island cheaper than New York?
Yes. A single person spends an estimated $1,328 per month in Staten Island versus $1,664 in New York — about 25% less.
How far is Staten Island from New York?
The straight-line distance between Staten Island and New York is approximately 23 km (14 miles).
Which city has better salaries, Staten Island or New York?
The estimated average net salary is $4,134 in Staten Island and $5,070 in New York. After living costs, a single person keeps roughly $2,806 in Staten Island versus $3,406 in New York per month.